Blumberg sign

Blumberg sign (rebound tenderness) is a physical examination finding characterised by pain on sudden release of pressure applied to the abdominal wall, particularly when the pain is greater than that experienced during compression.

It suggests irritation of the parietal peritoneum and may occur in acute appendicitis or other causes of peritonitis. It is not specific for appendicitis.

Examination technique

With the patient supine, the examiner applies gentle, gradually increasing pressure to the abdominal wall at the site being examined. The pressure is then released promptly.

Pain on release, particularly when greater than that experienced during compression, constitutes rebound tenderness.

The examination should be performed cautiously, avoiding unnecessary repetition in patients with marked abdominal tenderness or suspected peritonitis. Coughing, percussion or movement may provide alternative means of assessing peritoneal irritation with less discomfort.


Historical development

1907 – Jacob Moritz Blumberg (1873–1955) published Ueber ein diagnostisches Symptom bei Appendicitis in the Münchener medizinische Wochenschrift on 11 June.

Blumberg distinguished the pain produced by abdominal compression from that experienced when the palpating hand was suddenly withdrawn. Greater pain on release was suggestive of inflammation involving the peritoneum (peritonitis) and not purely associated with appendicitis.

Zunächst einen Druck auf die zu untersuchende Stelle des Abdomens auszuüben und den Patienten zu fragen, ob es schmerzt, dann nach erhaltener Antwort die palpierende Hand plötzlich abzuheben und nun sich von dem Patienten sagen zu lassen, ob im Moment des Abhebens es geschmerzt habe, resp welcher Schmerz grösser gewesen sei.

Die Methode lässt sich mit grösster Exaktheit anwenden, da es sich ja nicht um die Beurteilung der Grösse eines Schmerzes handelt, sondern um den Vergleich der Intensität zweier Schmerzen, und diese Angabe wird von den Patienten sehr zuverlässig gemacht. Blumberg, 1907

First of all exert pressure on the area of ​​the abdomen to be examined and ask the patient whether it hurts, then suddenly raise the palpating hand after receiving the answer and now let the patient tell you whether it hurt at the moment of lifting off or what pain was greater.

The method can be used with the greatest accuracy, since it is not a matter of assessing the size of one pain, but of comparing the intensity of two pains, and this information is very reliably given by the patient. Blumberg, 1907

1908 – Dmitri Sergeevich Shchetkin (1851–1923) presented a similar sign at a meeting of the Penza Medical Society on February 11, 1908. He stated that Russian clinicians had used the manoeuvre since the late 1880s, before Blumberg’s publication. The published description by Shchetkin has not yet been identified.

1909 – The Hospital published an English-language account of Blumberg’s examination, describing gradual pressure over McBurney point followed by sudden release. The report emphasised comparing pain during compression and release, and recognised that a positive result could occur in other causes of peritoneal inflammation.

1915 – Dmitri Shchetkin published О брюшном дрожании (On Abdominal Tremor) in Russkii Vrach. This has led to the term Shchetkin–Blumberg sign. However I have not yet found the original text to verify the paper’s relationship to rebound tenderness.

1970 – William G. Prout published The significance of rebound tenderness in the acute abdomen. He examined rebound tenderness in 100 patients with acute abdominal pain. He questioned its diagnostic usefulness and criticised the discomfort produced by the examination.

The physical sign of rebound tenderness has been studied in 100 patients with acute abdominal pain. In the majority of cases this sign proved unhelpful and was actually misleading in many instances. There seems little justification for the use of a sign which relies on causing a sudden and unexpected pain in a patient in whom confidence in the gentleness of the examining hand is vital.

Prout WG, 1970

1991 – Liddington and Thomson prospectively assessed rebound tenderness in 142 patients with abdominal tenderness. They found a sensitivity of 81% and specificity 49% in identifying peritonitis. They concluded the examination added little diagnostic value.

1996 – In Assessment of peritonism in appendicitis, Golledge and colleagues prospectively examined 100 patients presenting with right iliac fossa pain. They found sensitivity of 82% and specificity of 89% for diagnosing appendicitis. They concluded that rebound tenderness remained a useful component of clinical assessment.

2004 – Andersson published a Meta-analysis of the clinical and laboratory diagnosis of appendicitis. Rebound tenderness had a pooled positive likelihood ratio of 1.99 and negative likelihood ratio of 0.39, indicating modest diagnostic value as an individual finding.

2007 – In Does this child have appendicitis?, Bundy et al reviewed diagnostic findings in children with suspected appendicitis. They found that in selected paediatric populations, rebound tenderness had a summary LR+ of 3.0 and LR− of 0.28.

2019 – Rastogi et al reviewed the historical descriptions of Blumberg and Shchetkin, highlighting the development of the eponym and the diagnostic literature supporting rebound tenderness.


Diagnostic accuracy

The diagnostic performance of rebound tenderness varies between studies. This reflects differences in patient selection, examination technique and the diagnosis being investigated.

Liddington and Thomson (1991) found limited specificity for detecting peritonitis among patients admitted with abdominal tenderness, whereas Golledge and colleagues (1996) reported greater accuracy for diagnosing appendicitis in a selected cohort presenting with right iliac fossa pain.

Andersson (2004) reported a pooled LR+ of 1.99 and LR− of 0.39 for rebound tenderness in suspected appendicitis. Bundy and colleagues (2007) reported LR+ 3.0 and LR− 0.28 in selected paediatric populations.

In summary, rebound tenderness provides supportive evidence of appendicitis or peritoneal irritation, but cannot reliably establish or exclude either diagnosis in isolation.


Eponymythology

The sign is also known as the Shchetkin–Blumberg sign, particularly in Russian and Eastern European medical literature.

Shchetkin reportedly used a similar manoeuvre during the late 1880s. On February 11, 1908, he reported this earlier use at a meeting of the Penza Medical Society, following Blumberg’s publication in June 1907.

Later Russian sources support Shchetkin’s claim, however an original description or publication of the 1908 presentation has not been verified. His 1915 paper, On Abdominal Tremor, has also been associated with the eponym but no original paper has been reviewed.

Blumberg’s 1907 publication remains the earliest original description identified here. His emphasis on comparing pain during compression and release is not consistently preserved in contemporary descriptions or diagnostic studies.

Blumberg’s original descriptionModern interpretation
Assessed pain during pressure and releaseOften concentrates on pain upon release
Asked the patient which pain was greaterFrequently relies on a visible pain response
Sought evidence of peritoneal inflammationCommonly discussed as an appendicitis sign
Did not restrict the principle to one abdominal pointOften taught over the right iliac fossa

Associated Persons

References

Original articles

Review articles

eponymictionary

the names behind the name

BA MA (Oxon) MBChB (Edin) FACEM FFSEM. Emergency physician, Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital. Passion for rugby, medical history, medical education, and asynchronous learning #FOAMed evangelist. Editor-in-Chief and Webmaster of Life in the Fast lane, LITFL | On Call 4e| Eponyms | Books | Horology |

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.