Dunphy sign

Dunphy sign (cough tenderness; cough test) is the elicitation or exacerbation of abdominal pain by coughing, classically localised to the right iliac fossa in patients with acute appendicitis.

Technique: Ask the patient to cough before palpating the abdomen. A positive sign consists of pain provoked or intensified by coughing, often accompanied by a grimace, flinch or protective movement. Ask the patient to identify the location of maximal pain.

Coughing increases intra-abdominal pressure and produces movement of the abdominal wall and inflamed peritoneal surfaces, potentially eliciting pain in patients with localised peritoneal irritation. The sign is not specific to appendicitis and should be interpreted alongside the history, examination and other investigations.

Statistical evaluation of the cough test

Published estimates of diagnostic accuracy vary considerably, reflecting differences in patient selection, examination technique and the condition being diagnosed. Cough tenderness is a useful component of abdominal examination but cannot independently confirm or exclude appendicitis.

StudyPopulation / targetSensitivitySpecificity
Ben-Asher, 1943400 patients; uncomplicated appendicitis versus other abdominal diagnoses70.7%75.8%
Bennett at al, 1994143 analysable patients; peritonitis78%79%
Golledge et all., 1996100 patients with RIF pain; appendicitis82%50%
Idris et a., 2009866 patients selected for appendicectomy; appendicitis95.1%80%

History of Dunphy sign

1891 – Charles Heber McBurney (1845–1913) described pain provoked by coughing during the examination of patients with appendicitis. He observed that coughing could accentuate localised tenderness, particularly when combined with fingertip pressure over the right iliac fossa. An early published association between coughing and appendiceal inflammation, although the technique differs from the modern cough test.

…if firm pressure is made with the finger tip, and especially if the patient is made to cough while such pressure is being exerted, it is invariably easy to determine that the most sensitive point is a definite one in most cases. Generally the patient complains if the right thigh is overextended, and he will object if he is asked to cough.

McBurney 1891

1943 – Solomon Ben-Asher (1894–1949) published The value of the cough sign in acute appendicitis. He described a manoeuvre involving placement of the examiner’s fingertips beneath the left costal margin while the patient inhaled, exhaled and coughed. Among 400 patients, the sign was present in 70.7% of those with uncomplicated appendicitis compared with 24.2% of those with other abdominal diagnoses. Ben-Asher considered the sign valuable in differentiating appendicitis from other causes of abdominal pain.

For many years. I have utilized the cough sign in the examination of acute abdominal cases, and have found it of great value in the differential diagnosis, and almost pathognomonic of acute appendicitis. When positive, the patient will point to the area of the suspected appendix as the site of severe pain. This sign is rarely mentioned in text books on medicine, nor is it emphasized in the voluminous literature on this disease.

Solomon Ben-Asher 1943

1953 – John Englebert Dunphy (1908–1981) and Thomas W. Botsford published Physical Examination of the Surgical Patient, describing cough-provoked pain referred to the right lower quadrant in patients with acute appendicitis. Subsequent editions expanded on the value of eliciting cough tenderness before palpation and asking the patient to identify the site of pain.

The patient should first be asked to cough. In the presence of acute peritoneal inflammation this usually elicits a sharp twinge of pain localized to the involved area. It is extremely valuable to elicit this “cough tenderness” and have the patient point with one finger to the exact area of pain. This localizes the area of inflammation before the examiner so much as touches the abdomen. He can thus avoid palpating this area until the remainder of the abdominal examination is completed

Dunphy 1953

Many different options for this one…the most common derivation relates to one Osborne Joby Dunphy (1898–1989). However, I can find no reference to this individual, and no evidence of any publication relating to him or to his description of this sign.

1992 – Kenneth Waxman and G. Robert Mason used the term Dunphy’s sign in their chapter Appendicitis and Appendiceal Abscess in Mastery of Surgery. This is the earliest verified eponymous use identified in the sources reviewed to date.


Associated Persons

Eponymythology

The origin of the eponym Dunphy sign remains uncertain. The finding is commonly attributed to the American surgeon John Englebert Dunphy (1908-1981). In some secondary accounts the attribution is to Osborne Joby Dunphy (1898–1989), but no original publication documenting his description of the sign has been identified.


References

Original articles

Review articles

eponymictionary

the names behind the name

BA MA (Oxon) MBChB (Edin) FACEM FFSEM. Emergency physician, Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital. Passion for rugby, medical history, medical education, and asynchronous learning #FOAMed evangelist. Editor-in-Chief and Webmaster of Life in the Fast lane, LITFL | On Call 4e| Eponyms | Books | Horology |

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.