The Critical Debrief: Sedative Drug Overdose

The Critical Debrief: ASK PRAMOD – Sedative Drug Overdose

Keen to learn more from Pramod?  Pre-order his new book “Clinical Examination in Critical Care Medicine” – a gamechanger for learning clinical assessment skills in the critical care disciplines!  All proceeds go to our emergency medicine education charity Network Five Emergency Medicine!

Hosts: Shreyas Iyer, Pramod Chandru
Show Notes generated with AI assistance

⏱️ Episode Timestamps
00:00 — Disclaimer and intro
00:28 — Welcome — introducing the Ask Pramod series
00:50 — The paper: why the question, the cohort, and the findings
05:51 — Interpreting the pH 7.20 threshold
08:49 — The NICO trial, the six-hour observation strategy, and Australian practice
16:38 — At the bedside: airway mechanics, blood gases and drug factors
20:51 — Next steps, and sign-off

📚 References & Resources (in order of discussion)

Chandru P, Schriber K, Brasted HBF, Butler E, Gunja N (2026) — Risk Factors Associated with Deterioration in Sedative Drug Overdose. Journal of Medical Toxicology. 2026;22(2):296–304.
🔗 doi.org/10.1007/s13181-026-01120-0
⏱️ ~00:50
The paper under discussion. Retrospective cohort of 374 patients referred to a district toxicology service with suspected sedative overdose, November 2022 – November 2023. Common agents: benzodiazepines 32.1%, opioids 29.1%, GHB 20.6%. In-hospital complications 35.8%, ICU admission 17.9%, intubation 13.6%. ICU admission independently associated with lower venous pH and non-benzodiazepine GABA-ergic ingestion (adjusted OR 3.35, p = 0.04); in-hospital complications with opioid ingestion (adjusted OR 3.81, p < 0.001) and lower GCS. Modelled probability of intubation rose from 8% at pH 7.35 to 66% at pH 7.20. PMID 41792544.

Agency for Clinical Innovation, Emergency Care Institute — The Australian and New Zealand Emergency Department Airway Registry (ANZEDAR).
🔗 ACI Emergency Care Institute — Airway Registry
⏱️ ~01:32
The multicentre ED intubation registry referred to on air. Collects indication for intubation, first-pass success and complication rates across Australian and New Zealand EDs. Note: the specific proportion of ED intubations attributable to poisoning quoted in the discussion could not be verified against a published registry output and should be treated as the speaker’s recollection.

Freund Y, Viglino D, Cachanado M, et al. (2023) — Effect of Noninvasive Airway Management of Comatose Patients With Acute Poisoning: A Randomized Clinical Trial (NICO). JAMA. 2023;330(23):2267–2274.
🔗 doi.org/10.1001/jama.2023.24391
⏱️ ~08:49
The French trial discussed. Multicentre randomised trial across 20 emergency departments and 1 ICU, comatose patients with suspected acute poisoning and GCS < 9, May 2021 – April 2023. 225 patients (mean age 33); intubation 16% in the conservative arm vs 58% with routine practice; no in-hospital deaths. Primary outcome was a hierarchical composite of in-hospital death and ICU and hospital length of stay, favouring the conservative strategy (win ratio 1.85, 95% CI 1.33–2.58). Two corrections to the on-air description: this was a superiority trial using a win-ratio composite, not a non-inferiority study; and alcohol was the implicated toxin in 67% of cases, higher than the 40–50% recalled. The trial also excluded single-agent opioid and benzodiazepine ingestions, which strengthens rather than weakens the generalisability argument made in the episode.

Pellatt RAF, Isoardi K, Keijzers G (2023) — Intubation for patients with overdose: Time to move on from the Glasgow Coma Scale. Emergency Medicine Australasia. 2023;35(4):702–705.
🔗 doi.org/10.1111/1742-6723.14254
⏱️ ~10:28
The Emergency Medicine Australasia piece credited with prompting the study. Authors are from Gold Coast University Hospital, LifeFlight Retrieval Medicine and Princess Alexandra Hospital; Katherine Isoardi is a clinical toxicologist. It is an Opinion article rather than a letter to the editor. It proposes observation where toxicity is suspected to be short-lived — under 6 hours, or 8–12 hours depending on setting and resources — with airway reassessment if there is deterioration or coma persists beyond 6 hours. Note: the article text does not state an explicit pH 7.20 cutoff as a red flag; the speaker hedged on this point on air and it should not be attributed to this paper.

Background reading (not cited by name on air)

• Schaffer AL, Busingye D, Chidwick K, Brett J, Blogg S (2021) — Pregabalin prescribing patterns in Australian general practice, 2012–2018: a cross-sectional study. BJGP Open. 2021;5(1). doi.org/10.3399/bjgpopen20X101120
  Context for the PBS listing point raised in the episode: pregabalin was subsidised on the PBS for neuropathic pain in 2013, after which prescribing and related harm rose substantially. No specific source was named on air.

Also mentioned

• ‘GCS 8, intubate’ — the traditional teaching the episode argues against; no single source cited on air.
• Pramod Chandru’s forthcoming book on clinical assessment in critical care — pending publication, no citation available.
• The local clinical toxicology service now available to Nepean Hospital clinicians.
• Victorian epidemiological data on rising sedative overdose rates — referred to in general terms; no specific study was named and none has been cited here.

---

Listen in your favourite apps