Robert Reynolds Macintosh

Sir Robert Reynolds Macintosh (1897-1989) portrait

Sir Robert Reynolds Macintosh (1897-1989) was a New Zealand-born anaesthetist.

Macintosh was an educator and innovator who became the first Nuffield Professor of Anaesthetics at Oxford and one of the major figures in the development of modern academic anaesthesia.

Macintosh approached anaesthesia as a practical science centred on patient safety, physiology and simple reproducible equipment. His work ranged from wartime studies of artificial ventilation, hypoxia and survival at sea to investigations of anaesthetic mortality and the development of airway devices. He introduced the Macintosh laryngoscope in 1943, described the use of a gum-elastic tracheal tube introducer in 1949, co-developed the Epstein–Macintosh–Oxford inhaler, and later collaborated on an illuminated tracheal tube introducer.

Macintosh was influential through his teaching at Oxford, international training programmes, research into preventable anaesthetic deaths and the development of practical equipment for environments with limited resources.

Biography
  • Born on October 17, 1897 in Timaru, New Zealand, originally named Rewi Rawhiti Macintosh. He spent part of his childhood in Argentina, where he learnt Spanish, before attending Waitaki Boys’ High School in Oamaru.
  • 1915 – Commissioned into the Royal Scots Fusiliers before transferring to the Royal Flying Corps.
  • 1917–1918 – Shot down over France and held as a prisoner of war in Germany. Made several unsuccessful escape attempts and learnt German during captivity.
  • 1924 – Qualified MRCS LRCP from Guy’s Hospital Medical School, initially intending a career in surgery.
  • 1927 – FRCS Edinburgh. Increasing demand for his anaesthetic skills led him away from surgery and into a successful London private anaesthetic practice, later associated with the Mayfair Gas Company.
  • Early 1930s – Visited Ralph M. Waters in Madison, Wisconsin. The experience influenced his views on postgraduate teaching and departmental organisation.
  • 1937 – Appointed the first Nuffield Professor of Anaesthetics at Oxford, the first chair of anaesthesia outside the United States. The chair was established through the insistence of Lord Nuffield despite resistance within the University.
  • 1937 – Spent six weeks in Spain during the Civil War working with plastic surgeons treating war injuries. The experience reinforced the need for simple, portable anaesthetic equipment and contributed to development of the Oxford vaporiser with Kurt Mendelssohn and Hans Epstein.
  • 1939 – Passed the Diploma in Anaesthetics examination rather than receiving it by election; subsequently became a foundation Fellow of the Faculty of Anaesthetists in 1948.
  • 1939–1945 – Consultant/adviser in anaesthesia to the Royal Air Force and Royal Navy, holding the rank of Air Commodore. His Oxford department undertook wartime research into artificial ventilation, submarine atmospheres, high-altitude physiology and life-jacket design with Edgar Pask (1912-1966).
  • 1943 – Published A new laryngoscope in the Lancet, introducing the curved Macintosh laryngoscope blade.
  • 1943–1949 – Systematic investigation of anaesthetic accidents and deaths with William Mushin. Initial resistance from the Association of Anaesthetists was followed in 1949 by establishment of a committee to investigate deaths associated with anaesthesia.
  • 1949 – Published An aid to oral intubation, describing the gum-elastic introducer to guide larger endotracheal tubes.
  • 1955 – Knighted for services to anaesthesia.
  • 1965 – Retired as Nuffield Professor of Anaesthetics and became Emeritus Professor.
  • Died on August 28, 1989 in Oxford, England aged 91

Medical Eponyms
Macintosh Laryngoscope (1943)

In 1943 Macintosh introduced the Macintosh laryngoscope, designed around deliberate placement of the blade tip in the vallecula to elevate the epiglottis indirectly rather than lifting it directly.

Developed with his senior technician Richard Salt, the design allowed easier exposure of the larynx at lighter planes of anaesthesia and rapidly became one of the most widely adopted laryngoscope patterns in anaesthetic practice.

The history of its development, blade geometry, immediate naming by Stanley Rowbotham, manufacture and subsequent eponymythology are explored on the Macintosh laryngoscope.

Macintosh laryngoscope 1943 comparison 2

Fig 1A. This laryngoscope is designed to lessen the difficulty of exposing the larynx to pass an endotracheal tube. Normally the long straight blade of the standard laryngoscope is passed beyond the epiglottis in order to evert it.
Fig 1B The new laryngoscope is designed so that when its short curved blade is in position the tip will fit into the angle made by the epiglottis with the base of the tongue. Macintosh, Lancet 1943

Epstein–Macintosh–Oxford inhaler (EMO) (1952–1956)

The Epstein–Macintosh–Oxford (EMO) inhaler was a portable draw-over ether vaporiser developed by Hans Georg Epstein (1909-2002) and Macintosh at Oxford during the early 1950s.

The device evolved from the wartime Oxford Vaporiser No. 1, developed by Epstein, Macintosh and Kurt Mendelssohn (1906-1980) in 1941. The earlier vaporiser used a calibrated bypass system and thermal reservoir to provide a controlled concentration of ether without dependence on compressed-gas cylinders.

The EMO refined this principle with automatic temperature compensation, allowing a preset ether concentration to be maintained despite cooling of the ether during vaporisation. Designed in 1952, commercially produced from 1953 and formally described by Epstein and Macintosh in 1956, the portable apparatus became widely used in military, remote and resource-limited anaesthesia.

EMO inhaler and Oxford Bellows (1956)
EMO inhaler (1956). Left: section through the mature vaporiser showing the water jacket and automatic thermo-compensating bellows and plunger. Right: EMO connected to the Oxford Inflating Bellows and face mask for draw-over ether anaesthesia.

Key medical contributions
Wartime respiratory physiology and life-jacket research (1940s)

During the Second World War, Macintosh’s Oxford department undertook a wide range of applied respiratory and survival physiology for the British armed services. Projects included methods of artificial ventilation, maintenance of respirable atmospheres in submarines, problems associated with high-altitude flying and escape, and the design and testing of life-saving equipment. Macintosh served as an adviser in anaesthesia to both the Royal Air Force and Royal Navy and held the rank of Air Commodore.

Much of the experimental work was performed with Edgar Alexander Pask (1912–1966). In studies of survival at sea, Pask was anaesthetised to simulate an unconscious casualty and immersed in water while Macintosh and colleagues examined flotation posture and the ability of different life-jackets to keep the airway clear. Their wartime reports included Floating Posture of the Unconscious Body (1943) and Unconscious Flotation Posture: Tests of Eight Types of Life-Saving Equipment (1944).

The experiments were deliberately demanding. Pask was anaesthetised and intubated before being lowered into swimming pools and later exposed to rough-water conditions while wearing different flotation devices. The work demonstrated that simply providing buoyancy was insufficient. A life-jacket had to position an unconscious wearer so that the face and airway remained clear of the water. Macintosh and Pask subsequently reviewed this programme in The testing of life-jackets in 1957.

The department’s wartime programme extended beyond flotation. Further experiments included submarine escape, maintenance of breathable atmospheres and the physiological limits of high-altitude parachute escape without supplemental oxygen. These were hazardous experiments but emphasised their practical military purpose and the breadth of the Oxford department’s wartime research.

Macintosh used clinical anaesthesia as a foundation for solving broader problems of airway protection, ventilation, hypoxia and human survival rather than being confined to the operating theatre.

Pask and Macintosh testing life jackets anaesthetized 1941
Life-jacket experiments, 1940s. (A) Edgar Pask anaesthetised by Robert Macintosh before immersion testing; (B–C) flotation posture assessed with experimental buoyancy equipment in calm and rough water; (D) flotation without a life-jacket. Macintosh and Pask used anaesthesia to reproduce the behaviour of an unconscious casualty and assess whether life-saving equipment maintained the face and airway above water. Macintosh, Pask 1941-1957.
Gum-elastic tracheal tube introducer (1949)

In 1949 Macintosh published An aid to oral intubation, describing the use of a long gum-elastic catheter as an introducer for large-bore endotracheal tubes.

Macintosh found that larger oral tubes could obscure the view of the vocal cords during advancement. He therefore threaded the endotracheal tube over a malleable gum-elastic catheter and passed the catheter through the cords under direct vision. He then advanced the tube over the catheter and into the trachea. When laryngeal exposure was incomplete, the catheter could be curved and directed behind the visible epiglottis towards the glottis.

Gum-elastic tracheal tube introducer (1949)
Gum-elastic tracheal tube introducer (1949). Macintosh’s original illustration showing (1) passage of the introducer through the vocal cords, (2) advancement of the endotracheal tube over the guide, and (3) withdrawal of the introducer after the tube had entered the trachea

One of the difficulties in passing tubes beyond a certain size is that the body of the tube obscures the view of the cords through which the tip must be directed. In order to overcome this I thread the tube over a long gum-elastic catheter, the tip of which is then passed through the cords under direct vision (Figs. 1 and 2). Using the catheter as a guide the tube is gently pushed down into position (Fig. 3) and the guide is then withdrawn.

Macintosh, 1949

Macintosh’s technique established the principle of using a tracheal tube introducer when the endotracheal tube could not readily be directed through the glottis.

It was the purpose-designed Eschmann tracheal tube introducer, developed by British anaesthetist Paul Hex Venn (1923-2008) in 1973 which later became known as the “gum-elastic bougie”.


Illuminated tracheal tube introducer (1957)

In 1957 Macintosh and Harry Richards described an Illuminated introducer for endotracheal tubes, combining Macintosh’s earlier malleable gum-elastic introducer with Richards’ Flexo-metallic tube and bougie.

The other author [Richards] described a rigid metallic support to assist in the introduction of a flexo-metallic tube through the cords. This bougie, the end of which carries a lamp, has a curve similar to that of the well known Magill tube. It was designed not to project beyond the tip of the tube but to stop at it. It combined the function of splinting the flexo-metallic tube during its introduction, and illuminating the target, i.e. the cords.

The little device which is the subject of this short communication combines the better features of both its antecedents. The malleable introducer is 18 inches long so that it can be made to project well beyond the end of the tube. The outer casing is portex tubing which can be sealed off leaving a smooth translucent end.

Macintosh RR, Richards H. 1957

The resulting device was an 18-inch malleable introducer enclosed in Portex tubing with a smooth translucent tip containing an electric light. A flexible copper wire allowed the curve to be altered for individual anatomy, while the proximal connector could be attached to an ordinary pocket battery. The introducer projected beyond the endotracheal tube, allowing it to be directed through the glottis before the tube was advanced over it into the trachea.

Macintosh-Illuminated-introducer
Illuminated tracheal tube introducer (1957). Macintosh and Richards’ original illustration showing the malleable illuminated introducer projecting beyond the endotracheal tube and connected proximally to a pocket battery. The shape could be altered to suit the airway while the distal light illuminated the glottic target.

Macintosh and Richards reported that the light at the tip could provide sufficient illumination for intubation. They deliberately disconnected the laryngoscope bulb during trials and were still able to pass the tube under direct vision. On other occasions they exposed only the epiglottis with a tongue spatula and advanced the illuminated introducer into the larynx.


Anaesthetic mortality and patient safety (1943–1949)

During the 1940s Macintosh became increasingly concerned by unexpected deaths occurring during anaesthesia. He began collecting reports of anaesthetic accidents and deaths from hospitals, professional contacts and the press.

Working with William Woolf Mushin (1910-1993), Macintosh established a systematic investigation into the circumstances surrounding these deaths. They aimed to identify recurrent technical, organisational and clinical causes rather than accepting them as unavoidable complications of anaesthesia.

Their proposal initially met resistance within the profession. Macintosh continued to press for formal review, and in 1949 the Association of Anaesthetists established a committee to investigate deaths associated with anaesthesia.


Historical footnotes

Rewi Rawhiti. Macintosh was originally named Rewi Rawhiti Macintosh and his military records retain these given names. He later adopted Robert Reynolds Macintosh, the name under which he became internationally known.

Royal Scots Fusiliers. Macintosh is often described as a Royal Flying Corps pilot during the First World War. He was initially commissioned into the Royal Scots Fusiliers before transferring to the Royal Flying Corps. His military record records him as missing on May 26, 1917 and repatriated to Britain on December 17, 1918 after his period as a prisoner of war.

Date of birth. Some biographical sources give Macintosh’s date of death as August 23, 1989. Contemporary obituaries, the Royal College of Anaesthetists biography and his probate record give August 28, 1989, which should be regarded as the better-supported date.

The professor who sat the Diploma examination. Despite already holding the new Oxford chair, Macintosh did not receive the Diploma in Anaesthetics by election. The Radcliffe Infirmary did not satisfy the required definition of a teaching hospital, so Macintosh sat and passed the examination himself in 1939.

An All Black father. Macintosh’s father, Charles Nicholson Macintosh, was a New Zealand national rugby union player (debut 1893, Cap 39) and later mayor of Timaru (1901-1902).


Major Publications

References

Biography

Eponymous terms

Eponym

the person behind the name

Dr Alex Johnson LITFL Author

Doctor currently working in South Wales, training in anaesthetics. Graduated Leeds University with MB ChB with BSc in microbiology in relation to medicine. Special interests in emergency medicine, critical care and anaesthetics

BA MA (Oxon) MBChB (Edin) FACEM FFSEM. Emergency physician, Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital. Passion for rugby, medical history, medical education, and asynchronous learning #FOAMed evangelist. Editor-in-Chief and Webmaster of Life in the Fast lane, LITFL | On Call 4e| Eponyms | Books | Horology |

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.