Jack Barnes and the Irukandji Enigma
In 1961, Jack Handyside Barnes, his nine year-old son, and a local surf lifesaver were rushed to Cairns Base Hospital after developing Irukandji syndrome. Thus the riddle of what caused Irukandji Syndrome was solved; years of detective work had reached its climax in a dramatic and decisive episode of self-experimentation.
Jack Barnes was both a medical doctor and a former military commando. He was Medical Superintendent on Thursday Island in the Torres Straits from 1947, and from 1953 he worked as a general practitioner in Cairns. From 1945 onwards he was at the forefront of ongoing explorations in the burgeoning field of marine envenoming. Today, Barnes’ reputation is founded upon his discovery that a thumbnail-sized, nearly invisible, carybdeid (or four-tentacled box jellyfish) could cause Irukandji syndrome.
Queensland swimmers had noted a connection between marine stings and a previously undescribed but distressing illness as early as 1922. Eventually, the condition came under the scrutiny of radiologist and naturalist Hugo Flecker in the mid-1930s. Flecker described the characteristics of syndrome in 1945, but did not propose the name “Irukandji” until 1952: The name Irukandji has been chosen in the absence of knowledge of the identity of the offending object and of any distinctive character amongst the symptoms. It is the name of an aboriginal tribe which formerly inhabited the coastal region between the Mowbray River to the north and the Trinity Inlet around Cairns to the south. Most of the recorded victims were stung in this region, and although the injury is not limited to this area… no more appropriate geographical name can be found at present.Flecker, 1952
Southcott equated this Irukandji syndrome with what he termed “Type A Stinging”, a distinct entity to “Type B Stinging” which we now know to be caused by the larger multi-tentacled box jellyfish, Chironex fleckeri. Despite ongoing efforts the identity of the causative agent of Irukandji syndrome eluded both Flecker and Southcott, even in the face of drastic measures such as sieving the sea-water of the Cairns City Baths.
After the death of Flecker in 1957, Barnes was appointed to continue Flecker’s marine investigations. Suspecting that jellyfish were culpable, Barnes tried to retrieve nematocysts from the sting sites of Irukandji victims. He was only able to collect “an assortment of harmless contaminants”. Indeed, even today the low yield of nematocysts from skin scrapings and sticky-tape sampling of sting sites continues to dog investigators of Irukandji syndrome.
By logging records of marine stingings, from the Queensland Ambulance Transport Brigade and Cairns Base Hospital, Barnes was able to define the modus operandi of the as-yet-unknown offender. Stings occurred in December and January, with 85% of stings located on the contiguous Palm and Ellis beaches. Barnes realized that this was due to a marked change in the usual northward currents driven by south-easterly winds that are predominant in the Cairns area for most of the year. The stings were most numerous when winds blew steadily from the north, driving currents onshore. However, trying to identify candidate jellyfish at this time of year was impossible due to an “embarrassment of riches” in marine life – the fine-mesh nets Barnes tried to use clogged up with countless species of jellied life-forms in a matter of minutes.
Barnes’ detective work allowed him to make a few key deductions, leading him closer to his evasive prey. He deduced that the causative agent must be small, because victims were often only partially submerged in sea water or splashed by small wavelets washing over exposed skin, and would probably be found in surface water. It must also be colourless and transparent because no one could see the damned thing! And because stings tend to occur in “bursts”, when present the culprit species was likely to be found in large numbers. Finally the tiny beast must be mobile, because a likely causative agent had never been found stranded onshore.
Barnes realized that the best way to find such an elusive organism would be by capturing it underwater, using oblique light to render the tiny creature visible when looked upon through a diver’s face-mask.
On 10 December 1961, soon after the report of cases of Irukandji syndrome from the same area, Barnes and his helpers identified two specimens of a candidate species of jellyfish. Barnes was only able to see the body of the first specimen when he’d brought it into contact with the glass of his face-mask. The second specimen was captured by life-saver Don Ludbey, who only noticed the jellyfish because it was attached by a single tentacle to an erratically swimming fish!
At this point, Barnes still needed conclusive proof that the organism he’d found could cause Irukandji Syndrome. He decided to perform an experiment that would challenge even John Hunter’s auto-inoculation with venereal disease for sheer bravado.
Barnes’ description of the experimental stingings is remarkably detached and objective:
The first Carybdeid was applied to an adult (J.B.), and to a boy, aged nine years (N.B.). A robust young life-saver (C.R.) volunteered to test the second specimen, of similar size to the first.Barnes, 1964
I can only assume that with Christmas looming on the horizon, young “N.B.” must have negotiated an impressive wish list of presents before allowing his father to imperil his young life!
The rest is history:
The lad reported mild abdominal pain twelve minutes after being stung… As systemic effects became manifest, subjects were seized with a remarkable restlessness, and were in constant movement, stamping about aimlessly winging their arms, flexing and extending their bodies, and generally twisting and writhing… … muscle groups in tonic contraction, little short of spasm… and the volunteers adopted a stance which I can best liken to that of an infant with a full nappy… All had abdominal and back pain, pain in the anterior chest wall with some difficulty in breathing, and diffuse aches in muscles and joints……it was agreed that movement did not relieve symptoms, nor did pressure and rubbing… Forty minutes after the stinging, the abdominal musculature of the three subjects was in unrelenting spasm, so rigid as to warrant fully the term “board-like”. Vomiting… was not troublesome for some forty minutes. The adults obtained complete relief two minutes after the injection of 50 mg pethidine… Symptoms began to return 20 minutes after… As the effect of the second injection wore off, all subjects complained of neuralgic pains… and intermittent administration of aspirin was necessary for approximately 24 hours. Thereafter no ill-effects were apparent.Barnes, 1964
A full description of this malevolent little creature was published by Southcott in 1956. Southcott named the carybdeid jellyfish Carukia barnesi in honour of the intrepid Jack Barnes, with the generic name compounded from Carydea and Irukandji.
As well as identifying Carukia barnesi as a cause of Irukandji syndrome, Jack Barnes also identified the use of opioids as a useful treatment, proposed that other jellyfish may also cause “pseudo-Irukandji” syndromes, and instigated public health measures such as warning posters to educate the public. However, not even the impressive Dr. Barnes was always right – his advice to treat stings with methylated spirits should be disregarded; use vinegar instead!
- Barnes JH. Cause and Effect in Irukandji Stingings. Med J Aust. 1964 Jun 13;1:897-904.
- Flecker H. Injuries by unknown agents to bathers in North Queensland. Med J Aust, 1945; 1:98-.
- Flecker H. Irukandji sting to North Queensland bathers without production of weals but with severe general symptoms. Med J Aust. 1952 Jul 19;2(3):89-91.
- Flecker H. Fatal stings to North Queensland bathers. Med J Aust. 1952 Jan 12;1(2):35-8.
- Nickson CP, Waugh EB, Jacups SP, Currie BJ. Irukandji syndrome case series from Australia’s tropical Northern Territory. Ann Emerg Med. 2009 Sep;54(3):395-403 [PMID 19409658]
- Southcott RV. Fatal stings to North Queensland bathers. Med J Aust. 1952;1(8):272-274
- Southcott RV. Studies on Australian Cubomedusae, Including a New Genus and Species Apparently Harmful to Man. Australian Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research 1956;7(2): 254-280.
- Sutherland SK, Tibballs J (2001). Australian animal toxins: the creatures, their toxins and care of the poisoned patient. Melbourne, Oxford University Press.
- Irukandji syndrome
- Toxicology Conundrum 008
- Toxicology Conundrum 009
Chris is an Intensivist and ECMO specialist at the Alfred ICU in Melbourne. He is also a Clinical Adjunct Associate Professor at Monash University. He is a co-founder of the Australia and New Zealand Clinician Educator Network (ANZCEN) and is the Lead for the ANZCEN Clinician Educator Incubator programme. He is on the Board of Directors for the Intensive Care Foundation and is a First Part Examiner for the College of Intensive Care Medicine. He is an internationally recognised Clinician Educator with a passion for helping clinicians learn and for improving the clinical performance of individuals and collectives.
After finishing his medical degree at the University of Auckland, he continued post-graduate training in New Zealand as well as Australia’s Northern Territory, Perth and Melbourne. He has completed fellowship training in both intensive care medicine and emergency medicine, as well as post-graduate training in biochemistry, clinical toxicology, clinical epidemiology, and health professional education.
He is actively involved in in using translational simulation to improve patient care and the design of processes and systems at Alfred Health. He coordinates the Alfred ICU’s education and simulation programmes and runs the unit’s education website, INTENSIVE. He created the ‘Critically Ill Airway’ course and teaches on numerous courses around the world. He is one of the founders of the FOAM movement (Free Open-Access Medical education) and is co-creator of litfl.com, the RAGE podcast, the Resuscitology course, and the SMACC conference.
His one great achievement is being the father of three amazing children.
On Twitter, he is @precordialthump.
| INTENSIVE | RAGE | Resuscitology | SMACC
My father, John Meredith, succeeded Jack Barnes as the Medical Superintendent of Thursday Island hospital and our family moved into the Barnes’s former home in John Street in 1952. Much of the area under the house was taken up with the half tanks in which he conducted his marine experiments.
Tragically, his older daughters died young due to an inherited disease and were buried in the Thursday Island cemetery where my sisters and I often played.
I hope the male child on whom he performed the experiment survived to adulthood. I heard one, perhaps this one, became a solicitor.
I think he deserves a bronze statue in his honour for his efforts and for not testing it on animals.